Sunday May 23, 1999 On The Nine
Network Australia
Big Brother is listening
Reporter:
Ross Coulthart Producer: Nick Farrow
In
this Sunday investigation, Australia's
spy-chiefs acknowledge for the first time this
country's role in an international spying
alliance that is monitoring the overseas phone,
fax and email messages of every Australian –
indeed, everyone on the planet.
This
top-secret American operation, known as Echelon,
spies on the rest of the world and, as Sunday
reporter Ross Coulthart reveals, may even be
used against Australia.
Among the people Coulthart talks to is a
former spy for Canada's Communications Security
Establishment, the arm of the UKUSA intelligence
alliance, which includes Australia, Britain, the
US, Canada and New Zealand.
Among the things Mike Frost, the former spy,
says CSE was asked to do was to spy on two of
Margaret Thatcher's Cabinet -- the request
coming from then British Prime Minister Thatcher
-- and bug the mobile phone of Margaret Trudeau,
the wife of the then Canadian Prime Minister,
Pierre Trudeau.
Frost explains why he thinks the Echelon
system is dangerous: "I say, never
over-exaggerate the capacity of a system such as
Echelon. Never ever over-exaggerate the power
that these organisations have to abuse a system
such as Echelon. Don't think it can't happen in
Australia. Don't think it can't happen in
Canada, because it does."
In an unprecedented statement to the Sunday
program, the director of Australia's Defence
Signals Directorate (DSD), Martin Brady, reveals
what spying the DSD allows on Australian
citizens and companies. DSD also officially
acknowledges for the first time that it is a
signatory of the hitherto secret UK-USA
alliance, that endorses cooperation with
counterpart intelligence organisations in the
United Kingdom, the US, Canada and New Zealand.
The DSD documents are available here - just
click on the following links:
Defence Signals Directive letter from Martin
Brady to Sunday:
Page One
Page Two
Page Three
Additional information related to this story,
can be found by clicking on the link to Full
Transcript at the top right of this page. We
have also compiled:
Echelon Frequently Asked Questions
and Website Links and Duncan Campbell's
piece on the European Parliament's report on
Intelligence Gathering. For links to IGIS
documents, please read on.
The DSD also details to the Sunday
program, some of the checks DSD maintains over
its extraordinary spying powers, which until now
have all remained strictly classified in an
internal DSD document called Rules on Sigint and
Australian Persons.
As the program reveals, Australia is
routinely monitoring any fax, phone or data
communications passing through satellites over
the Indian and Pacific Ocean. The interception
of these communications is controlled by a
so-called "dictionary system" that
scans all communications simultaneously with the
use of powerful super-computers that have been
programmed with key words, key numbers and even
specific voice patterns. Some of the intercepted
messages (which do include communications by
Australians) are sent to Australia's DSD but the
bulk of the intelligence from Australia's
important Geraldton base is sent automatically
to America without scrutiny by Australian eyes.
This complex computer surveillance system is
known by the codename "Echelon".
Coulthart travelled to the United States to
interview former spies with the American
National Security Agency (NSA) and intelligence
commentators. They warn that, with the end of
the Cold War, the NSA is and has been using its
intercept facilities around the world, including
Australia, to procure valuable commercial
intelligence. The program details a number of
reported examples where the NSA has used the
Echelon system to give American companies a
trade advantage.
Sunday asks if, in the light of strong
evidence from overseas, Australia is not being
naïve in its relationship with its American
allies – they have been and continue to be our
solid allies in defence but can we trust them
not to abuse this extensive spy system to give
their companies a trading edge. The program also
raises concerns, including allegations from a
former spy who worked for the NSA, that this
powerful spy system has been abused and
threatens the privacy of every citizen.
Australia's Inspector-General of Intelligence
and Security, Bill Blick, tells the program that
he is certain Australia can trust DSD and the
American allies who spy with DSD on Australian
soil through facilities such as Geraldton in WA
and Pine Gap in the Northern Territory.
The IGIS' written statement to Sunday
is available here by clicking on the following
links:
Letter from Inspector-General of
Intelligence & Security to Sunday:
Page One
Page Two
Page Three
DSD director Martin Brady also details how
the classified Sigint Rules “…do provide
mechanisms to permit DSD to monitor and report
foreign communications involving Australians in
some special carefully-defined circumstances
such as the commission of a serious criminal
offence; a threat to the life or safety of an
Australian; or where an Australian is acting as
the agent of a foreign power.”
DSD tells the Sunday program that
Australians are spied on infrequently and “safeguards
are provided to ensure that the privacy of
Australians is not compromised.” Indeed, the
spy-chief reveals how the Sigint Rules generally
“…prohibit the deliberate interception of
communications between Australians in Australia;
the dissemination of information relating to
Australian persons gained accidentally during
the course of routine collection of foreign
communications; or the reporting or recording of
the names of Australian persons mentioned in
foreign communications.”
But the program reveals how even inside DSD
there is concern that these rules are not
enshrined in legislation. Nearly half a decade
after the inquiry into ASIS, Australia's
overseas spy service, recommended all the spy
services all be put under an act of parliament,
DSD still only operates at the whim of a
directive of politicians in cabinet.
And, in the light of evidence Sunday
has obtained from overseas spies, can we trust
our UK-USA allies?
|